TradeZella alternative: Beyond Replay compared
TradeZella is one of the best-known trading journals. Beyond Replay is new, comes from Austria and combines a coach for trading psychology with replay backtesting. Here is the honest comparison.
Comparison, as of 19 October 2026
In short
Both combine a journal, AI and backtesting. TradeZella has more brokers, more markets and a learning section. Beyond Replay is cheaper to start with, has a free tier, trade replay from the smallest paid tier and Edge, a coach who trains your psychology.
Beyond Replay suits you if
- you want a coach who knows your trades and works with you on fear, greed and revenge trades
- you want to start for free, without a subscription
- you need trade replay and AI backtests already in the small tier
- you want to backtest tick by tick, not just in one-second steps
- a server in Germany and prices in euros matter to you
TradeZella is a better fit if
- you want to backtest stocks or crypto
- your broker isn't supported by us but is among TradeZella's 500+ brokers
- you are looking for courses, webinars and a large community
What Beyond Replay does differently from TradeZella
Tick-by-tick backtesting
From Pro you replay the market tick by tick: every single price change, not in steps of seconds or minutes. When scalping, you see exactly whether your stop or your target would have been hit first. On request, Edge checks this for every trade against the real price action.
TradeZella lists 1-second charts for backtesting on its pricing page.

A coach for your psychology
Most losses happen in your head. Edge spots fear, greed, revenge trades and rule breaks in your trades, keeps a handbook about you and works on them with you, week by week, until the mistakes become fewer. From Pro he checks in before the session and pulls the emergency brake after two losses.
TradeZella's Zella AI analyses trades, writes reports and has agents for tags, sessions and market sentiment.
Beyond Replay and TradeZella at a glance
| As of: 19 October 2026 | Beyond Replay | TradeZella |
|---|---|---|
| Free tier | Yes, 1 live journal | Not on the pricing page |
| Entry tier, monthly | €29 net (Starter) | $35 (Essential) |
| Entry tier, yearly, per month | €24.17 net | $26 |
| Middle tier, monthly | €49 net (Pro) | $59 (Pro) |
| Top tier, monthly | €89 net (Elite) | $99 (Ultra) |
| AI day to day | Edge, coach for trading psychology, from Starter | Zella AI with 500 to 3,000 AI credits |
| AI backtests per month | 2 / 10 / 100 | 1 trial run / 10 / 100 |
| Replay backtesting | From Starter, 21 markets, 5 years | All tiers, stocks, futures, crypto, CFDs |
| Backtesting precision | Seconds (Starter), tick by tick (from Pro) | 1-second chart |
| Trade replay | From Starter | From Pro |
| Active accounts | 1 / 3 / 50 / unlimited | 1 / 50 / unlimited |
| Brokers | 10 connections, CSV from 15+ platforms | 500+ brokers |
| Mentor access | Free in every tier | Mentor Mode |
| Prop firm | Real-time protection, 22 templates (Elite) | PropFirm-Sync overview |
| Learning section and community | No | Zella University, community |
Source: tradezella.com/pricing (accessed on 19 October 2026). Our prices net in euros plus VAT; other providers' prices as stated there.
Prices compared
Beyond Replay
- Free€0, 1 live journal, import, statistics, notebook
- Starter€29 a month, yearly €24.17 a month
- Pro€49 a month, yearly €40.83 a month, 7-day free trial
- Elite€89 a month, yearly €74.17 a month
Prices net in euros, plus VAT (Austria 20 %). Cancel monthly.
TradeZella
- Essential$35 a month, yearly $26 a month ($315 a year)
- Pro$59 a month, yearly $44 a month ($531 a year)
- Ultra$99 a month, yearly $74 a month ($891 a year)
In US dollars, according to TradeZella's pricing page. No free tier is offered there.
Is Beyond Replay cheaper than TradeZella?
For the entry tier, yes: Starter costs €29 net a month, TradeZella's Essential $35. We also have a free tier; TradeZella's pricing page does not.
What's in the tier matters more than the price. Trade replay and AI backtests come with Starter at Beyond Replay, at TradeZella from Pro. In return, TradeZella's Essential includes manual backtesting for stocks, futures, crypto and CFDs.
What does Edge do differently from Zella AI?
Both read your trades and answer questions. Edge is built as a coach for trading psychology: he keeps a handbook about you, spots patterns like revenge trades and trains them with you, week by week.
From Pro, Edge reaches out on his own: a check-in before the session, a weekly review on Sunday and a stop after two losses. You can also give him your own guards, for example “Warn me after 11 am”.
Does Beyond Replay support as many brokers as TradeZella?
No. TradeZella lists more than 500 brokers. Beyond Replay connects directly to TopstepX, MetaTrader 4 and 5, cTrader, NinjaTrader 8, Interactive Brokers, TradeLocker, DXtrade, OKX, Bybit and Binance, and reads CSV exports from more than 15 platforms as well as PDF account statements.
If Beyond Replay doesn't recognise a file, Edge finds the way with one click.
How good is the backtesting in comparison?
Beyond Replay replays the market candle by candle, with real price data from 21 markets (major indices, key forex pairs, gold, silver) over 5 years. Starter works with second data, Pro tick by tick. There is a live sim mode without rewinding, and your own spreads and fees, for example for Topstep or FTMO.
TradeZella covers more asset classes, including stocks and crypto. If you mainly trade indices, forex or gold, you get everything you need with us.
Where TradeZella is ahead
No tool is the best for everyone. Here the other provider is stronger:
More brokers
More than 500 brokers according to TradeZella; we have 10 direct connections plus CSV import.
More markets in backtesting
Stocks, futures, crypto and CFDs. We have 21 markets, without stocks and crypto.
Learning section and community
Zella University with webinars, and a community. We have neither.
Well-known name
TradeZella cites more than 100,000 traders. Beyond Replay launched in 2026.
Switch from TradeZella in three steps
Create a free account
No subscription. The free account stays free for as long as you like.
Bring in your trades
Connect your broker (for example TopstepX, MetaTrader, cTrader, NinjaTrader) or upload your broker's CSV export. Beyond Replay recognises the format by itself.
Meet Edge
Try Pro for 7 days: Edge sees your trades, explains your patterns, and you practise in replay backtesting.
How we compared
We opened the official pricing pages of all providers on 19 October 2026 and only took what is stated there. You'll find the links below the table.
We show prices in the currency the provider uses. We don't convert them, because exchange rates fluctuate and taxes vary by country.
We are Beyond Replay and therefore not neutral. That's why every page also shows where the other provider is better.
Prices and features change. If you find a mistake, write to support@beyondreplay.com and we'll correct it.
Frequently asked questions
Can I take my trades from TradeZella to Beyond Replay?
The easiest way is to connect your broker directly to Beyond Replay or upload your broker's CSV export. Your trades then land in the journal with entry and exit to the second.
Is Beyond Replay available in German?
Yes. Beyond Replay comes from Austria, and the app and Edge speak German. The website is available in German, English, French, Dutch and Italian.
Can I try Beyond Replay before I pay?
Yes. The free tier is free forever. You can try Pro free for 7 days.
Where is my data stored?
On our own server in Germany. Every account is separate, you can export your data at any time and delete your account yourself.
More comparisons
Edge is already waiting for your first trade.
Start for free. You can try Pro for 7 days.

