Ask EdgeAnswers instantly

FX Replay alternative: Beyond Replay compared

FX Replay specialises in backtesting. Beyond Replay combines replay backtesting with your live journal and a coach who sees both. Here is the comparison.

Comparison, as of 19 October 2026

Replay backtesting in the app: NAS100 on the 5-minute chart

In short

If you only want to backtest, FX Replay is cheaper. If you want backtesting, a live journal with broker import and a coach for trading psychology in one tool, Beyond Replay is the alternative.

Beyond Replay suits you if

  • you want to compare backtests and real trades in one place
  • your trades should come into the journal automatically from your broker
  • you need tick-by-tick backtesting already in the middle tier
  • you want a coach who sees your backtests and live trading together

FX Replay is a better fit if

  • you only want to backtest and have a small budget
  • you want to use the free tier just for backtesting
  • you want to compete with others in backtesting contests

What Beyond Replay does differently from FX Replay

Tick-by-tick backtesting

From Pro you replay the market tick by tick: every single price change, not in steps of seconds or minutes. When scalping, you see exactly whether your stop or your target would have been hit first. On request, Edge checks this for every trade against the real price action.

FX Replay lists second data, and only in the Pro tier.

Edge rewinding a candlestick chart

A coach for your psychology

Most losses happen in your head. Edge spots fear, greed, revenge trades and rule breaks in your trades, keeps a handbook about you and works on them with you, week by week, until the mistakes become fewer. From Pro he checks in before the session and pulls the emergency brake after two losses.

FX Replay lists AI questions; its pricing page does not list a coach for trading psychology.

Edge chat in the app with a real daily check-in

Beyond Replay and FX Replay at a glance

As of: 19 October 2026Beyond ReplayFX Replay
Free tierJournal, without backtesting2 backtest sessions, 1 indicator, 1 week of data
Entry tier, monthly€29 net (Starter)$17.99 (Intermediate)
Entry tier, yearly, per month€24.17 net$15
Full tier, monthly€49 net (Pro)$35 (Pro)
Backtest sessionsUnlimited from Starter10 (Intermediate), unlimited (Pro)
Second dataFrom StarterPro only
Tick by tickFrom ProNot on the pricing page
Futures dataIndex prices, no CME futuresFutures and CME data in Pro only
Live journal with broker importYes, free tooNot on the pricing page
AIEdge, coach for trading psychology, from StarterLimited (Intermediate) or unlimited AI questions (Pro)
AI backtest in words2 / 10 / 100 a monthNot on the pricing page
Monte Carlo simulationCoin-flip testYes, from Intermediate
Prop-firm protection in real timeYes (Elite)Not on the pricing page

Source: fxreplay.com/pricing (accessed on 19 October 2026). Our prices net in euros plus VAT; other providers' prices as stated there.

Prices compared

Beyond Replay

  • Free€0, 1 live journal, import, statistics, notebook
  • Starter€29 a month, yearly €24.17 a month
  • Pro€49 a month, yearly €40.83 a month, 7-day free trial
  • Elite€89 a month, yearly €74.17 a month

Prices net in euros, plus VAT (Austria 20 %). Cancel monthly.

FX Replay

  • Beginnerfree, 2 sessions, 1 indicator, 1 week of data retention
  • Intermediate$17.99 a month or $180 a year
  • Pro$35 a month or $350 a year

In US dollars according to FX Replay's pricing page; taxes may apply.

Why backtesting and journal in one tool?

Most traders backtest in one program and keep their journal in another. Then nobody sees whether you trade live the same way you do in the backtest.

At Beyond Replay both sides sit side by side. Edge sees your backtest sessions and your real trades and tells you where the gap opens up.

Is FX Replay cheaper?

Yes, if it's only about backtesting. FX Replay's Intermediate costs $17.99 a month, Pro $35. Our Starter costs €29 net, Pro €49 net.

In return, our tiers also include the live journal with broker connection, Edge as a coach and the AI backtest. Second data comes with Starter, tick data from Pro.

Which markets can I backtest?

Beyond Replay has 21 markets with 5 years of history: the major indices, the key forex pairs, gold and silver. New prices are added daily.

If you need real futures data from the CME, FX Replay offers it in the Pro tier.

Where FX Replay is ahead

No tool is the best for everyone. Here the other provider is stronger:

Cheaper for pure backtesting

From $17.99 a month, yearly from $15.

Try backtesting for free

The free tier includes 2 backtest sessions. With us, backtesting comes with Starter.

Real futures data

CME data in the Pro tier. We work with index prices.

Large community

Backtesting contests (FXR Battles). Beyond Replay launched in 2026.

Switch from FX Replay in three steps

  1. Create a free account

    No subscription. The free account stays free for as long as you like.

  2. Bring in your trades

    Connect your broker (for example TopstepX, MetaTrader, cTrader, NinjaTrader) or upload your broker's CSV export. Beyond Replay recognises the format by itself.

  3. Meet Edge

    Try Pro for 7 days: Edge sees your trades, explains your patterns, and you practise in replay backtesting.

How we compared

We opened the official pricing pages of all providers on 19 October 2026 and only took what is stated there. You'll find the links below the table.

We show prices in the currency the provider uses. We don't convert them, because exchange rates fluctuate and taxes vary by country.

We are Beyond Replay and therefore not neutral. That's why every page also shows where the other provider is better.

Prices and features change. If you find a mistake, write to support@beyondreplay.com and we'll correct it.

Frequently asked questions

Is Beyond Replay a replacement for FX Replay?

Yes, if you backtest indices, forex, gold or silver. You step through candle by candle, place orders with your own spread and get statistics per session. Plus the live journal.

Is there a mode without rewinding?

Yes. In live sim mode the market keeps running as if it were real, and you can't rewind. That way you practise under real conditions.

Can I see news in the backtest?

Yes. Economic events appear as markers on the chart, with details on click. You can also skip news times.

More comparisons

Edge is already waiting for your first trade.

Start for free. You can try Pro for 7 days.