Ask EdgeAnswers instantly

The best trading journal 2026: six tools compared honestly

Which trading journal suits you? We compared Beyond Replay, TradeZella, Edgewonk, FX Replay, TraderSync and Tradervue. We are Beyond Replay, so we are not neutral. That's why every tool shows who it's best for, even when that isn't us.

Comparison, as of 19 October 2026

Edge pointing at a rising curve

Our take

Beyond Replay

Best for traders who want to work on their psychology

Journal, tick-by-tick replay backtesting and Edge, a coach for trading psychology, in one. Free tier, from €29 net a month. Server in Germany, available in German.

Start for free
Journal in the app: monthly calendar with profit and loss per day
  1. TradeZella

    Best for many brokers and markets

    More than 500 brokers, backtesting with stocks, futures, crypto and CFDs, learning section. From $35 a month, no free tier on the pricing page.

    Beyond Replay and TradeZella compared
  2. Edgewonk

    Best for the lowest yearly price

    One plan with all features and unlimited journals. $197 for 12 months, 14-day money-back guarantee.

    Beyond Replay and Edgewonk compared
  3. FX Replay

    Best for pure backtesting on a small budget

    Specialised in backtesting, with a free tier. Intermediate from $17.99 a month, futures data in Pro.

    Beyond Replay and FX Replay compared
  4. TraderSync

    Best for stocks and options

    AI assistant, market replay down to 250 milliseconds, options spreads, phone app. From $29.95 a month.

    Beyond Replay and TraderSync compared
  5. Tradervue

    Best for classic reports on stocks

    More than 100 reports, unlimited accounts, mentors and community sharing. Silver $29.95, Gold $49.95 a month.

    Beyond Replay and Tradervue compared

All six at a glance

As of: 19 October 2026Beyond ReplayTradeZellaEdgewonkFX ReplayTraderSyncTradervue
Free tierYesNot on the pricing pageNoYes, backtesting7-day trialFree plan mentioned
Entry tier, monthly€29 net$35Yearly plan only$17.99$29.95$29.95
Entry tier, yearly, per month€24.17 net$26approx. $16.42$15$22.46Not on the pricing page
Live journal with broker importYesYesYesNot on the pricing pageYesYes
Replay backtestingYesYesNot on the pricing pageYesYesNot on the pricing page
Backtesting precisionTick by tick (from Pro)1 second–Seconds (Pro)down to 250 ms (Elite)–
AI coach or AI assistantEdge, coach for psychologyZella AIEdge Finder (weekly)AI questionsCypherNot on the pricing page
Prop-firm protection in real timeYes (Elite)PropFirm-SyncNot on the pricing pageNot on the pricing pageNot on the pricing pageNot on the pricing page
Stocks in backtestingNoYesNot on the pricing pageNot on the pricing pageYesNot on the pricing page

Beyond Replay

Free tier
Yes
Entry tier, monthly
€29 net
Entry tier, yearly, per month
€24.17 net
Live journal with broker import
Yes
Replay backtesting
Yes
Backtesting precision
Tick by tick (from Pro)
AI coach or AI assistant
Edge, coach for psychology
Prop-firm protection in real time
Yes (Elite)
Stocks in backtesting
No

TradeZella

Free tier
Not on the pricing page
Entry tier, monthly
$35
Entry tier, yearly, per month
$26
Live journal with broker import
Yes
Replay backtesting
Yes
Backtesting precision
1 second
AI coach or AI assistant
Zella AI
Prop-firm protection in real time
PropFirm-Sync
Stocks in backtesting
Yes

Edgewonk

Free tier
No
Entry tier, monthly
Yearly plan only
Entry tier, yearly, per month
approx. $16.42
Live journal with broker import
Yes
Replay backtesting
Not on the pricing page
Backtesting precision
–
AI coach or AI assistant
Edge Finder (weekly)
Prop-firm protection in real time
Not on the pricing page
Stocks in backtesting
Not on the pricing page

FX Replay

Free tier
Yes, backtesting
Entry tier, monthly
$17.99
Entry tier, yearly, per month
$15
Live journal with broker import
Not on the pricing page
Replay backtesting
Yes
Backtesting precision
Seconds (Pro)
AI coach or AI assistant
AI questions
Prop-firm protection in real time
Not on the pricing page
Stocks in backtesting
Not on the pricing page

TraderSync

Free tier
7-day trial
Entry tier, monthly
$29.95
Entry tier, yearly, per month
$22.46
Live journal with broker import
Yes
Replay backtesting
Yes
Backtesting precision
down to 250 ms (Elite)
AI coach or AI assistant
Cypher
Prop-firm protection in real time
Not on the pricing page
Stocks in backtesting
Yes

Tradervue

Free tier
Free plan mentioned
Entry tier, monthly
$29.95
Entry tier, yearly, per month
Not on the pricing page
Live journal with broker import
Yes
Replay backtesting
Not on the pricing page
Backtesting precision
–
AI coach or AI assistant
Not on the pricing page
Prop-firm protection in real time
Not on the pricing page
Stocks in backtesting
Not on the pricing page

Sources: tradezella.com/pricing, edgewonk.com/pricing, fxreplay.com/pricing, tradersync.com/pricing, tradervue.com/site/pricing (accessed on 19 October 2026). Our prices net in euros plus VAT; other providers' prices as stated there.

What to look for in a trading journal

Do you learn from it?

A journal is only as good as what you change because of it. Look for analytics that tell you what to change, not just numbers.

Do the trades come in by themselves?

If you have to type in every trade, you'll stop after two weeks. A broker connection or CSV import is a must.

Can you practise?

Replay backtesting helps you train your strategy before you risk real money.

Does the price fit?

Work it out per year and look at what's in the tier you actually need.

How we compared

We opened the official pricing pages of all providers on 19 October 2026 and only took what is stated there. You'll find the links below the table.

We show prices in the currency the provider uses. We don't convert them, because exchange rates fluctuate and taxes vary by country.

We are Beyond Replay and therefore not neutral. That's why every page also shows where the other provider is better.

Prices and features change. If you find a mistake, write to support@beyondreplay.com and we'll correct it.

Frequently asked questions

Do I even need a trading journal as a beginner?

Yes. Especially at the start, a journal shows you which mistakes keep repeating. Many tools have a free tier or a trial, so start with that.

Which trading journal is available in German?

Beyond Replay comes from Austria, and the app and coach speak German. For the other providers, check whether their language works for you.

Which tool is the cheapest?

For pure backtesting FX Replay, for a year of journaling Edgewonk. You can start for free with Beyond Replay and FX Replay.

More comparisons

Edge is already waiting for your first trade.

Start for free. You can try Pro for 7 days.