Ask EdgeAnswers instantly

How to keep a trading journal: what to log and how to learn from it

A trading journal is more than a list of wins and losses. Kept properly, it shows you why you win, why you lose and which habit costs you the most. Here's what belongs in it and how to learn something from it every week.

Guide, updated October 2026. 5 min read

Journal in the app: monthly calendar with profit and loss per day

In short

Log every trade with its numbers, its reason and how you felt, ideally right after. Review it once a week with the same questions, then change exactly one thing.

Why keep a trading journal?

Without records you mostly remember the big wins and the painful losses. Everything in between blurs. A journal replaces that impression with facts: which setups really work? At what time of day do you lose? What happens after two losses in a row?

For prop traders there's more to it: when you write down your rule breaks, you see when and why they happen, and you can stop them before they cost you an account.

Read next: Passing a prop firm challenge

What should a trading journal include?

The numbers

  • Date and time of entry and exit
  • Market and direction, long or short
  • Entry, stop, target and exit
  • Position size and risk in money or percent
  • Result after fees, ideally also as a multiple of your risk (R)

The reason

  • Which setup was it? Give every setup a fixed name.
  • Why right here? One sentence is enough.
  • Did the trade follow your rules, yes or no?
  • A chart screenshot at entry and at exit

Your head

  • How did you feel before the trade? Calm, impatient, anxious, greedy?
  • What did you do during the trade? Move the stop, exit early, add to it?
  • What shape were you in that day? Sleep, stress, distractions.

The third part is the one most people skip, and it's often the most important. Many losses don't start on the chart. They start in your head.

When should you log a trade?

As soon as possible after the trade, while you still remember what you were thinking. By the evening the numbers are still there, but the reason and the feeling have already been polished.

To keep it up, it has to be quick. Import the numbers automatically wherever you can and spend your effort on the reason and the feeling. A short voice note right after the trade is often more honest than a paragraph written that evening.

How do you learn from your journal?

Logging alone changes nothing. The learning comes from the review. Block half an hour once a week and go through the same questions every time:

  1. Which trades followed my rules, which didn't, and how did each group do?
  2. Which setup made the most, which one cost the most?
  3. At what times and on which days do I lose?
  4. What happened after losses? Were there revenge trades?
  5. Where did I exit too early, where did I move my stop?

Finish by writing down one single change for next week, for example: no trades after 11 am. One change you actually stick to is worth more than ten good intentions.

Which reports actually help?

  • Results by setup: shows which ideas carry you and which to drop.
  • Results by time of day and weekday: shows when you're at your best and when to sit out.
  • Rule-following versus rule-breaking trades: shows what your rule breaks cost you.
  • MAE and MFE: how far price moved against you and in your favour. They show whether your stops are too tight or your targets too small.
  • Results by emotion: shows the state you're in when you make your worst decisions.

What mistakes do people make with their journal?

  • Logging only wins and losses, without reasons or feelings.
  • Leaving out losing trades because they're uncomfortable.
  • Logging everything but never reviewing it.
  • So many fields that after two weeks nobody fills them all in.
  • Mixing prop and personal accounts in one journal until the numbers mean nothing.
  • Mixing backtest trades with real trades.

Spreadsheet or journal app?

A spreadsheet is fine to start with. It gets tedious once you have lots of trades, want to store screenshots or break results down by time and setup. A journal app pulls trades from your broker, does the maths for you and saves you the typing.

In the end, the tool matters less than using it every trading day.

Read next: Learning to backtest

Checklist for every entry

  • Numbers complete: time, market, direction, entry, stop, target, result
  • Setup with a fixed name
  • One sentence on the reason
  • Followed the rules: yes or no
  • How you felt before and during the trade
  • Chart screenshot
  • One lesson, if there is one

How Beyond Replay helps

Beyond Replay's journal fills itself. Connect your broker or upload the export, and every trade lands in the journal down to the second. You add emotions per trade or a voice note, and keep your prop account and personal account apart. Calendar, reports and the discipline curve are free; from Starter, MAE and MFE are added automatically.

From Starter, Edge, your coach for trading psychology, reads along and spots your patterns. From Pro, he checks in on his own, for example with a weekly review on Sunday.

Statistics in the app: equity curve and key metrics

About this guide

This guide describes how many traders keep their journal. Take what suits you and drop whatever you'd stop filling in after two weeks.

No guide replaces personal advice. This text is not investment advice. Trading leveraged products such as CFDs, futures and forex carries a high risk of loss. Backtest results are no guarantee of future results.

Guide, updated October 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What should I write in my trading journal?

For every trade: the numbers (time, market, direction, entry, stop, target, result, risk), the reason (setup and one sentence on why) and your state of mind (how you felt before and during the trade). Plus a chart screenshot.

How often should I review my journal?

Once a week with a fixed set of questions, plus a quick look at the end of each trading day. More important than how often is taking exactly one change away from every review.

Is an Excel spreadsheet enough as a trading journal?

To begin with, yes. With many trades, screenshots and breakdowns by setup or time, a spreadsheet soon becomes tedious. A journal app imports trades automatically and calculates the metrics for you.

Should I log backtest trades in my journal too?

Yes, but separately from real trades. That way you can compare whether you trade live the way you did in the backtest. In Beyond Replay every backtest session has its own journal.

Does a journal help with a prop firm challenge?

Yes. Writing down rule breaks and emotions shows you the situations in which you put limits at risk, so you can avoid them on purpose. Keep prop accounts in a journal of their own.

More guides

Edge is already waiting for your first trade.

Start for free. You can try Pro for 7 days.